What happens when you stumble into a town where every day is Halloween, the vampires are real, and your only way to survive is to pretend you’re someone’s mail order bride? That’s the playful setup of Kristen Painter’s The Vampire’s Mail Order Bride.
The premise grabbed my attention not to mention, what is more October vibes then a Halloween Town? Delaney is on the run and pretending to be a mail order bride for a brooding vampire. It was enjoyable, but I was left with more “meh” feeling than “must read.”
Writing, Plot & Communication Tropes
Painter has a knack for fun world-building. Nocturne Falls is charming in its Halloween-everyday weirdness: witches, werewolves, gargoyles, tourists, and real supernatural politics all mixed in. Delaney’s backstory gives decent stakes, and there are additional conflicts. It was nice that the storyline was not just romantic tension, but also had secrets, pursuit, family expectations.
Where things falter is a little bit in execution. The writing is decent, not bad, nor remarkable. To me, the pacing drifts. The novel starts off with good momentum, but then it slows in the middle. Some of the conflicts are resolved too hastily, I felt there should be a bit more friction for some of the resolutions. Also, the non-communication trope is in there. I fully understand this is a very common trope, and I will give it to the author that it is NOT the main driving trope in some respects, there is still a pretty big thing that I just kept thinking, this should be done now. It does NOT completely kill the story, but it does dull tension because you know some of the friction is manufactured rather than organic.
Character Development & Chemistry
Delaney is a heroine you can root for. She’s resourceful and quick on her feet, trying to escape a dangerous situation while still keeping her humor and warmth intact. Occasionally her inner monolog was a bit too much for me, buy overall she is an enjoyable FMC. She’s sweet, spunky, with quirks (baking, making up food-themed curse words, etc.) that give her personality. She’s one of the stronger points.
Hugh, in contrast, carries the weight of centuries. As a vampire, he’s dignified and controlled, but that control sometimes veers into aloofness. His sense of duty and fear of repeating past mistakes make him guarded, which can be frustrating, but it also adds depth to his reluctance. When the walls finally start to crack, the glimpses of vulnerability beneath his brooding exterior make his character more engaging. I did find him a bit frustrating than compelling at times. His reluctance is understandable, but they sometimes drag the story when he’s overly mopey or avoiding conflict.
Together, they strike a balance between Delaney’s quirky and Hugh’s restraint. The dynamic between them doesn’t always sizzle, but is enough to pull the romance through. This is a closed door romance.
Final Thoughts 
Overall, The Vampire’s Mail Order Bride is one of those books that does a lot right—and yet, never quite rockets into “love it” territory for me. It’s charming, has enough originality in its premise and setting, and is a good comfort read if you want something paranormal + romantic + easy. It won’t blow your socks off, but it also won’t offend; it’s more cute than compelling.
If you’re like me and not super fond of non-communication tropes, this might still work for you because the other conflicts help, but be prepared for some predictable moments. If you want sharper tension, steamier romance, or more emotional stakes, it may leave you wishing.
Would I recommend it? Yes, with caveats. It’s great for fans of cozy paranormal romance, or if you want a lighter vampire romance rather than a darker, heavier fare.
What do you think? Would you give it a try?
NOTE! Check my Socials, I like to create Nail Art that match the vibe of the books I read!
Hazel Harbor Books 
Leave a comment