“What wasn’t known was created, what wasn’t created eventually ceased to matter. It’s a form of pragmatism, I suppose. Warm, loving, people who desperately need approval from others fall victim to to Stockholm syndrome, while the rest of us fall to pragmatism. Having seen both sides in others, I’m for Pragmatism.”
— Dot Hutchison, The Butterfly Garden
Rereading The Butterfly Garden reminded me why I loved it the first time around. It’s one of those rare thrillers that manages to be disturbing, emotional, and deeply compelling all at once. Even knowing how the story unfolds, I found myself drawn right back in — proof of how effectively Hutchison builds tension and atmosphere.
The Writing
The writing is clean, direct, and easy to follow, which makes the darker elements of the story all the more impactful. Hutchison’s pacing is steady, allowing each reveal and emotional beat to land. The narrative structure, told through an interrogation, still feels clever and immersive, pulling readers into the mindset of the main character while maintaining a haunting sense of suspense. The thriller and creep factor are just as effective the second time around. Hutchison strikes a careful balance between unsettling and compelling — never glorifying the horror, but using it to explore control, trauma, and resilience. The contrast between the “garden’s” beautiful setting and its dark purpose gives the book an eerie, unforgettable edge.
The Characters
The characters are one of this book’s strongest points. Each of the “butterflies” feels distinct, with their own reactions, fears, and survival instincts. Even on a reread, I noticed new layers in their interactions and resilience. The arcs feel organic, some heartbreaking, and they make the story feel grounded despite its horrific premise.
Final Thoughts
The Butterfly Garden held up beautifully on reread. It’s well-written, emotionally charged, and haunting in all the right ways. The story, characters, and tone remain consistent and powerful throughout. If you enjoy thrillers that delve into the psychology of survival and the strength of human spirit, this book is absolutely worth picking up — or revisiting.
Have you read this one before? If not, are you going to give it a try?
Hazel Harbor Books 
Leave a comment