When a newly separated mom accidentally unleashes her family’s long-dormant magic, she must navigate small-town chaos, unexpected romance, and a deck of enchanted tarot cards that might change her fate.
I picked up Playing the Witch Card expecting a light, magical romance — and while there is a romance subplot tucked inside its pages, the heart of this story turned out to be something much deeper and more meaningful. Instead of a straightforward love story, I found a beautifully layered tale about healing, rediscovering yourself, and finding community in unexpected places. And honestly? I loved it.
A Healing Journey at the Center
The book focuses primarily on the FMC’s emotional journey, and it’s written with an honesty and tenderness that took me by surprise. Her struggles, her grief, and her slow return to herself felt incredibly grounded, even within a book full of magic and whimsy. Watching her grow, reclaim her voice, and rebuild pieces of her life was easily my favorite part. It added a richness to the story that made it far more than just a romantic or magical escape.
Magic, Whimsy, and the Perfect Little Witchy Town
The setting was an absolute delight. The witchy town has that perfect cozy-fantasy charm — full of small-town quirks, magical touches, and characters who feel both mystical and very human. The magical elements are fun, vivid, and woven into daily life in a way that adds personality and atmosphere without overshadowing the emotional core. Every description made me want to step into the town myself, explore its shops, and follow its spells.
Romance as the Soft Subplot
While romance isn’t the primary focus, the romantic arc that develops adds warmth and sweetness to the book. It supports the FMC’s healing rather than overtaking it, which made it feel natural and well-balanced. It’s the kind of subplot that enhances the story instead of distracting from it.
Final Thoughts
Even though it wasn’t what I expected going in, Playing the Witch Card ended up being a fantastic read — heartfelt, magical, and wonderfully written. If you enjoy books about personal growth with a sprinkle of spellcraft, a supportive community, and a touch of romance, this one is absolutely worth picking up.
Do you think you will give Playing the Witch Card a try? Are you into witchy fiction?
Hazel Harbor Books 
Leave a comment